with the confirmation of the top 5
carley smithson clearly did not make it into that 5 . but why ?
top 6 performances kicked on tuesday seeing almost everyone except brooke white and jason castro singing well that night .
so why is carley out ? , she is one of the most well deserving contestant to be there , with great vocals and good performance , she should have been in top 2
sorry idols , u have just made a big mistake .
What should have been out was either Brooke or Jason
Clearly NOT CARLEY …
but yet we say goodbye to another great in idol ,
goodbye carley
keep singing u will do well darling !
